Section 5 of the Public Order Act specifically calls for a license to be issued
by the Executive or law enforcement authority of The Gambia before
processions can be held. Similarly, Article 11 of the African Charter
provides for that the exercise of this right shall be subject only to necessary
restrictions provided for by law in particular those enacted in the interest of
national security, the safety, health, ethics and rights and freedom of
others.
While it is submitted that the restrictions contained in Section 5 of the
Public Order Act should not be seen as a tool in the hands of the Executive
and law enforcement agencies to impinge on the guaranteed rights of
persons under Article 11 of the Charter making it impracticable for
individuals to enjoy their Human Rights, the positive obligation of ensuring
national security, safety, peace and order should not be disregarded.
The Respondent further argued that the Applicants have not established a
violation of Article 11 and that in any event it does not reside in this court to
embark on an examination of laws of Member States but rather to protect
the rights of citizens when violated.
In the case of FEDERATION OF AFRICAN JOURNALISTS V. REPUBLIC
OF THE GAMBIA, (2108) ECW/CCJ/JUD/04/18, the Court having
reiterated its human rights competence found that it has the powers to go
into the root of the violation i.e. those laws which the Applicants are
contesting to establish whether or not they are contrary to the provisions of
international human right laws on freedom of expression.
The Respondent further argued that the tenor of the Public Order Act is
regulatory of the right to assembly rather than prohibitive and the provisions
are reasonably necessary to achieve legitimate aims to ensure public
safety and public order. Assemblies of a public character raise a number of
practical issues that ought to justify at least a minimum amount of
consultation with the authorities regarding time, location, traffic
management and other factors. These issues may include safety, security
and inconvenience or even economic loss to those affected by the peaceful
assembly. Hence, certain forms of regulation, such as the requirement to
33