Communication 431/12 – Thomas Kwoyelo v. Uganda
90. The State avers that the ICD is a special division of the High Court which was
created in 2008 in furtherance of the Government’s obligations under the 2007 Juba
Agreement on Accountability and Reconciliation. Further the ICD was aimed at
meeting Uganda’s obligation to complement the work of the International
Criminal Court [ICC] in prosecuting gross violations of human rights and grave
breaches of the Geneva Conventions (war crimes).18
91. In response to allegations relating to the denial of amnesty, the Respondent states
that whereas it did grant amnesty to various members of rebel groups in different
parts of Uganda who renounced rebellion, the Complainant has not discharged his
duty to show that the circumstances of their grant of amnesty were similar to the
Victim’s own arrest and prosecution.
92. The Respondent is of the view that the Complainant has not adduced evidence that
the said amnesty reporters from different rebel groups in Uganda (including
women and formerly abducted child soldiers and persons) were suspected or
accused of committing or had particular responsibility for gross human rights
violations, war crimes, or international crimes. As per the State, there is no
evidence that these reporters had been criminally charged with such crimes at the
time of applying for amnesty. The Respondent opines that such facts cannot be
assumed in the absence of witness evidence of their involvement in such crimes.
93. According to the Respondent State there was evidence of the Victim’s
participation or responsibility for grave breaches of Geneva Conventions, for
which he is being prosecuted. In respect to the grant of amnesty to former LRA
high ranking Brigadiers Sam Kolo and Kenneth Banya, the Respondent states that
the circumstances of their arrest were different from those prevailing at the time of
the Victim’s arrest.
Attached to the submissions of the Respondent are excerpt from the ICD website and the
Agreement on Accountability and Reconciliation, and its Annexure.
18
22
62nd Ordinary Session, 25 April – 9 July 2018