For the reasons stated above, the Community Court of Justice, sitting in public after
hearing the parties, and their submissions duly considered in the light of the provisions of
the African Charter on Human and People’s Rights, and also the Supplementary Protocol
of the Court and the Court’s Rules of Procedure, decides as follows:
1. The unlawful killing of Mr. Abutu Adamu was a breach of Article 4 of the ACHPR
and declares that the Respondent violated the same.
2. The Respondent failed to carry out proper investigations into the allegation of
murder in order to identify the perpetrators and to prosecute same in accordance
with the law resulting in a breach of Article 4 of the ACHPR and a violation of the
same.
3. That the Applicants as victims on their own rights, are entitled to compensation for
the damages suffered.
Orders and awards
In consequence of which the Court orders the Respondent as follows;
1. To pay to the Applicants the sum of 50,000,000 (Fifty Million Naira) to be shared
equally as compensation for moral and material damage.
2. To pay the sum of 2,500,000 Million Naira (Two Million Five Hundred Thousand
Naira) as costs to the Applicants.
THIS DECISION IS MADE, ADJUDGED AND PRONOUNCED PUBLICLY BY THIS
COURT, COMMUNITY COURT OF JUSTICE, ECOWAS; SITTING AT ABUJA,
NIGERIA ON THE DAY 9th DECEMBER, 2019.
HON. JUSTICE Dupe ATOKI - PRESIDING
HON. JUSTICE Keikura BANGURA – MEMBER
HON. JUSTICE Januária T. S. M. COSTA - MEMBER
Mr. Tony ANENE-MAIDOH – Chief Registrar
16