A/HRC/22/44
The Working Group adopted, at its sixty-fifth session, its Deliberation No. 9
concerning the definition and scope of arbitrary deprivation of liberty under customary
international law. The Working Group found that the prohibition of all forms of arbitrary
deprivation of liberty forms a part of international customary law and constitutes a preemptory or jus cogens norm.
The report concludes that the prohibition of arbitrariness in customary international
law comprises thorough examination of lawfulness; reasonableness; proportionality and
necessity of any measure depriving a human being of his or her liberty. It also concludes
that administrative detention should only be permitted in strictly limited circumstances.
In its recommendations the Working Group requests States to enforce the protection
of every person’s right to liberty under customary international law; ensure that the
available guarantees and safeguards are extended to all forms of deprivation of liberty,
including for example house arrest, re-education through labour, protective custody,
detention of migrants and asylum seekers, detention for treatment or rehabilitation and
detention in transit areas; and ensure that persons are not held in pretrial detention for
periods longer than those prescribed by law as well as ensuring that such persons are
promptly brought before a judge. All detainees should benefit from all minimum
procedural guarantees, including the principle of equality of arms; the provision of
adequate time and facilities for the preparation of the defence; proper access of evidence;
and guarantees against self-incrimination.
2
GE.12-18935