;· r) 6�!jE'aB
r
Human s;ghts ou,
Human and Peoples' Rights
Collective Respons,bihty
78 days of his detention, no criminal charges were brought against him,
indicating a lack of sufficient prima facie evidence or reasonable suspicion of his
involvement in any offense. Furthermore, the Complainant contends that his
deprivation of liberty, primarily based on his perceived opposition to the
regime, along with how he was arrested and detained, renders the situation
unjust, inappropriate, and fundamentally incompatible with the principle of
due process.
�<m»:(•
.
138.
In the case of Patrick Okiring and Agupio Samson (represented by
Human Rights Network and ISIS-WICCE) v. Republic of Uganda, the
Commission held that the right to liberty functions as a significant safeguard,
ensuring that every arrest or detention is conducted in a manner that is neither
unlawful nor arbitrary. 42
139.
The Commission has also held that the right to liberty is a significant
guarantee that any arrest or detention should not be unlawful or arbitrary.43
Therefore, any deprivation of liberty that occurs without due process, the legal
safeguards of a fair trial, or for unacceptable or arbitrary reasons constitutes a
violation of Article 6 of the African Charter. The Commission affirms that the
right to liberty entails more than just physical freedom - it encompasses the
fundamental principle that individuals should not be subjected to arbitrary or
unlawful deprivation of their liberty. The right to liberty includes the right to
due process and fair treatment in accordance with the law. 44
140.
Therefore, any act depriving individuals of their liberty without proper
legal justification or violating their right to a fair trial violates Article 6 of the
African Charter. The Commission's stance emphasizes the critical importance
of upholding the principles of due process, fair trial, and non-arbitrary
detention to protect individuals' rights to liberty and shield them from
unlawful or arbitrary deprivation of their freedom.
141.
Moreover, the Principles and Guidelines on the Right to a Fair Trial and
Legal Assistance in Africa further underscore the obligations of State Parties
42 Communication 339/2007 - Patrick Okiring and Agupio Samson (represented by Human Rights Network and ISIS
WICCE) v. Republic of Uganda para 107.
43 In the case of Patrick Okiring and Agupio Samson (represented by Human Rights Network and ISi
of Uganda,
44 Communication 339/2007 - Patrick Okiring and Agupio Samson (represented by Human Rights N
WICCE) v. Republic of Uganda para 107.
44 Communication 379/09 - Monim Elgak, Osman Hummeida and Amir Suliman (represented by Fl
para 103.
An O!gan orlhe
Afriqan c,))
Union -,,,;f
32
African Com
31 Bijilo n
ghts
�11:tl::::!��
istrict,
West Coast Region, The Gambia
Phone: (220) 230 4361 Fax: (220) 441 05 04
Email: au-banjul@africa-union.org
https:/achpr.au.int/0 0 a