Costed Action Plan for SADC Industrialization Strategy and Roadmap
Ownership and Embeddedness
As illustrated in Lesotho, Madagascar and Mauritius, different patterns of ownership
give rise to different value chain strategies. As ownership changes – the relative pullback of some Western investors and their replacement by Asian, Latin American,
Central European as well as African investors, both domestic and foreign –
embeddedness characteristics change and with them their value chain strategies.
Value chain participation may start regionally and graduate to the global level or work in
the reverse direction, from global to regional. However, because the majority of SADC
Member States have broadly similar industrial structures, the scope for the relocation of
labour-intensive tasks to low-wage economies is limited, though there are cases where
South African and Mauritian firms outsource such manufacturing activities to other
countries within the SADC Free Trade Area. For further dimensions see Box 2.1.
Box 2.1: Country Specificities
All countries engage in value chain activities to some extent, though in SADC the bulk of participation
is forward rather than backward and global rather than regional. The strategies outlined in the SADC
Industrialization Strategy and Roadmap focus on enhanced domestic value-addition leading to
reduced backward integration and enhanced forward integration. This follows from the fact that as
backward integration declines due to greater domestic value-addition, forward integration increases
because of the enhanced domestic value addition.
There is a direct link between the pattern of resource endowment and the nature and extent of value
chain participation. Within SADC, because exports are overwhelmingly resource-based with limited
domestic value-addition, forward integration is dominant. Similarly, because regional usage of
unprocessed and semi-processed primary products is limited, the volume of intra-regional trade is
small as also is the extent of regional value chain participation.
Typically, backward linkages develop in the earlier stages of industrialization as countries reduce
dependence on agriculture and mining. Forward linkages become dominant again as economies shift
towards service-driven growth and the evolution of Headquarter as distinct from Factory economies.
Accordingly, value chain participation is U-shaped in nature with forward integration declining as
countries industrialize and backward integration increases. Thereafter, forward integration levels off
and starts to increase again with the transition to services-led growth.
Countries with higher per capita incomes tend to have higher forward participation rates. This is
certainly the case in some SADC economies – notably Angola, Botswana and South Africa.
The share of MVA in GDP is positively correlated with value chain participation. In SADC, the share of
MVA in GDP has fallen significantly over the last 20 years, which helps to explain the underdevelopment of cross-border value chains in the region.
25