A/HRC/22/44 GE.12-18935 Opinion No. Country Government’s reply Person(s) concerned Opinion 19/2012 Yemen No Abbad Ahmed Sameer Detention arbitrary, categories I and III 20/2012 Israel No Hana Yahya Shalabi Between 16 and 23 February 2012: detention arbitrary, categories I and III; after 23 February 2012: detention arbitrary, category III 21/2012 Philippines Yes Marcus Haldon Hodge Detention arbitrary, category III 22/2012 Saudi Arabia No Rabie Mohamed Abdelmaksoud, Jumaa Abdallah Abusraie, Awad Al Sayed Zaky Abu Yahya, Sameh Anwar Ahmed Al Byasi, Abu Al Aineen Abdallah Mohamed Esaa, Youssef Ashmawy, Ahmed Mohamed Al Said Al Hassan, Khaled Mohamed Moussa Omar Hendom, Abdullah Mamdouh Zaki Demerdash, Mustafa Ahmed Ahmed El Baradei, Hassan Anwar Hassan Ibrahim, Abdul Rahman Mahmoud Ibrahim Zeid Detention arbitrary, categories I and III 23/2012 Cuba Yes Yusmani Rafael Álvarez Esmori and Yasmín Conyedo Riverón Between 8 January and 5 April 2012: detention arbitrary, categories II and III 24/2012 Cuba Yes José Daniel Ferrer García The Working Group decided to request more information both to the Government and to the source 25/2012 Rwanda No Agnès Uwimana Nkusi and Saïdati Mukakibibi Detention arbitrary, categories II and III 26/2012 Sri Lanka Yes Pathmanathan Balasingam and Detention arbitrary, Vijiyanthan Seevaratnam categories I and III 27/2012 Viet Nam Yes Le Cong Dinh, Tran Huynh Duy Thuc, Nguyen Tien Trung and Le Thang Long Detention arbitrary, category II 28/2012 Venezuela (Bolivarian Republic of) No Raúl Leonardo Linares Amundaray Detention arbitrary, category III 29/2012 China Yes Gulmira Imin Detention arbitrary, category II 7