whereas American legislation required such document for the movement of the
atiefacts on its territ01y.
14. Moreover, the said State Depai1ment explains that in reality, the Applicant had
abandoned his collection in the basement of the Embassy and did not entrust it to
anybody's care, not even to his successor.
15. It was therefore by mere chance that the collection was discovered in 1971
during a mission of the Inspectorate General of the Administrative, Financial and
Economic Affairs, at Washington.
16. Thus, after an auditing, the administrative authorities handed over the said
items to the Applicant against an acknowledgement of receipt.
17. As regards the Application, the State Department for Disputes concluded its
views that it should be purely and simply rejected on the grounds that:
• The Court of Justice of ECO WAS is incompetent to adjudicate on the case,
having regard to Atticles 9 and 10 of the 2005 Supplementary Protocol on
the said Court
• The defect of status of the Applicant
18. A first transit session of the Court on this Case was held at Bamako on 2
October 2006. On preliminary grounds, the issue of competence of the Comi was
put fmih by the State Department for Disputes, which asked for a written Reply
from the Applicant. The latter applied for adjournment for that purpose. The Case
was thus adjomned to 4 October for a Rejoinder from the Applicant, who on that
date, was represented by a lawyer.
19. From the Application instituting proceedings, founded on the remedying of
wrongs caused him by the State of Mali, the resultant Rejoinder opted for the
violation of Hunran-Rights-which haO allegedly--been -co1nmitted by tlie-Sfate ·of
Mali against the Applicant.
APPRECIATION OF THE ARGUMENTS OF THE PARTIES
20. In his Application instituting proceedings, Moussa Leo Kei'ta does not found
his claims on a precise text of law nor on the positive law of the Community. He
simply invoked the wrongs caused him by the State he had loyally served in the
4
Downloaded from worldcourts.com. Use is subject to terms and conditions. See worldcourts.com/terms.htm