e~'H'~,AC H P R
.,
African Commission on
Human and Peoples' Rights
Human Rights our
Collective
Responsibility
bitch and -slut used when referring to them, the complainant specifically stated that
out of all protesters arrested and who were taken to the military prison on 10 March
2011, they were the only who were subjected to forced genital examinations together
with other five, identified as unmarried.w
94. The Complainants submitted that the sexual humiliation manifesting repeated verbal
abuse, electroshocks and beatings, dragging the Complainants by their headscarf,
threats of beatings, electroshocks, and strip searches in full view of others, (which
qualify the acts to be torturous) against them was deliberate to send a message to other
women engaged in protests that they risk suffering the same fate if they engage in
activities related to the protest movement. This included.f!
95. The Complainant also cited Curtis Francis Doebbler v .Sudan62 and African Commission,
Media Rights Agenda v Nigeria63 and argued that the Commission does not explicitly
distinguish between torture and ill-treatment in interpreting the scope of Article 5, but
calls for as widely as possible interpretation to encompass the widest possible array of
physical and mental abuses. They also cited Gabriel'Shumba v Zimbabuie+, and Sudan
Human Rights Organisation & Centre on Housing Rights and Evictions (COHRE) v Sudan,65
with the position that Article 5 is aimed at the protection of both the dignity of the
human person and the
physical and mental integrity of the individual subject to Article
.
1 of the UN Convention against Torture and other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading
Treatment or Punishment (UN Torture Conventionj.w
.
96. The Complainants submitted that the treatment inflicted on the Victims resulted in
physical injuries and psychological trauma.s? The First Victim testified that following
the ill-treatment at the museum and military prison she came -out as a wreckpsychologically, physically and emotionally and that her entire body had marks from
61
See, Section 0: Analysis of Articles 2 and 18 (3) Violations on the complainant Submission on Merit
See, Paragraph 124 of the Submission on Merits
62
Communication 236/00, para.37
63
Communication No. 224/98, para 71
64
Communication 288/04, para.l43
65
Communications 279/03-296/05 para.156
66
See, Paragraph 124 and the referred notes thereat.
60
::.-.,. "
AfricanI
Union
"I