has no jurisdiction to extend the time and therefore the Court cannot proceed
to grant interim or any orders on such an Application.
Citing Article 30 (1) and (2) of the Treaty Counsel for the 2nd Respondent
submitted that the Reference should have been filed within two months from
the date the acts complained of happened or from the date the Applicants
became aware of them. The present Reference, she argued, meets neither of
those Treaty requirements. She contended that the present Application which
arises from the Reference is time barred.
She argued that Article 30 (2) of the Treaty reflects the principle that a cause
of action arises when a state of facts occurs which gives a potential claimant a
right to succeed against a potential defendant. She further argued that the
Article also recognizes that where applicable, time to file a Reference does not
begin to run until a claimant becomes aware of the alleged unlawful act or
infringement complained of. However, after a person becomes aware of the
said action, the stipulated time of two months begins to run and the time limit
is thus imposed. She further contended that Article 30 (2) of the EAC Treaty
does not legally recognize any “continuing” breach of violation of the Treaty
outside the two months after a relevant action comes to the knowledge of the
Claimant.
Counsel contended that although the Applicants had sought to rely on Rules
1(2) and 4 of the East African Court of Justice Rules of Procedure, (“the
Rules”), those Rules do not grant the Court any jurisdiction outside the Treaty
but are themselves subject to the provisions of the Treaty. In support of her
stance she cited Article 9 of the Treaty which provides, inter alia, that Organs
of the Community shall perform their functions within the limits of the powers
conferred by/or under the Treaty.
1st Respondent’s Submissions
Mr. Edwin Okello, Counsel for the 1st Respondent, associated himself with the
2nd Respondent’s submissions and added that the proceedings provided for in
the Article 30 (2) must be instituted within two months of enactment,
publication, directive, decision or action complained of.
4