219/98 Legal Defence Centre / Gambia (The)
Summary of Facts
1. The Complainant is an NGO based in Nigeria and has observer status with the African Commission on
Human and Peoples' Rights.
2. The Complainant alleges the illegal deportation of a Nigerian national from The Gambia.
3. It is alleged that the deportee, Mr Sule Musa, was a journalist with the "Daily Observer", a Gambian
newspaper.
4. It is alleged that one Corporal Nyang arrested Mr Sule Musa within the premises of his office. After his
arrest he was taken to the Bakau Police Station from where he was directed to surrender his international
passport. He was then driven home to fetch his passport and afterwards taken to the Police headquarters
in Banjul, and from there to the Immigration Department, where he was told he was being deported to go
and face trials for crimes he committed in Nigeria.
5. It is alleged that on arrival at the airport on 9th June 1998, Mr Sule Musa was neither allowed food, water,
or a bath, until 10th June 1998 after he had been served with his deportation order for being an "undesirable
alien".
6. The Complainant alleges that Mr Sule Musa was being deported for his writings in the "Daily Observer"
on (certain) diverse issues concerning Nigeria, under the military regime of General Sani Abacha.
7. It is alleged that upon his arrival in Nigeria there was no immigration or police officer to arrest him for the
purported crimes he had committed in Nigeria.
8. Furthermore, the Complainant alleges that Mr Sule Musa was not allowed to take any of his personal
effects before he was deported. Inevitably, his property is in The Gambia, while he is in Nigeria and cannot
return as the deportation order still subsists.
Complaint
9. The Complainant alleges that the following articles of the African Charter on Human and Peoples' Rights
have been violated: Articles 7, 9, 12(4), 2, 4, 5 and 15.
Procedure
10. The Complaint is dated 27th July 1998 and was received at the Secretariat of the Commission on 9th
September 1998.
11. At the 24th Ordinary Session, the Commission decided to be seized of the complaint and parties were
informed accordingly.
12. The Commission at its 25th Ordinary Session held in Bujumbura, Burundi, postponed consideration of
the communication to the next session while requesting the Secretariat to investigate whether the
Complainant could have recourse to the local courts in The Gambia.
13. Letters were sent to the parties by the Secretariat requesting for additional information on the
availability of local remedies but no response has been received.
14. Furthermore, the Secretariat established contact with the Attorney General of The Gambia and solicited
her assistance. This resulted in a meeting on 10th March 2000, at the Secretariat of the Commission
between the State Counsel in the Department of State for Justice and the Legal Officer at the Secretariat.
The State Counsel promised to send their submissions on all the complaints but the submissions promised
were not sent.
Law
Admissibility
15. Article 56(5) of the Charter provides:
Communications...shall be considered if they:
1