contact with a child or deal with a matter in which a child is involved. Therefore,
prison officials, police officials and justice officials would fall within the ambit of this
provision. Lastly, Article 4(1) requires that the best interests of the child be the
primary consideration in matters involving children. Therefore persons dealing with
matters involving children, within the ambit of the African Children‟s Charter, should
ensure the best interest of the child as the final outcome.
23. The best interests of the child must be the primary consideration in relation to all
actions that may affect children whose parents are in conflict with the law, whether
directly or indirectly, in accordance with Article 4. States should create and
implement laws/policies to ensure this at all stage of judicial and administrative
decision-making during the criminal justice process, including arrest, pre-trial
measures, trial and sentencing, imprisonment, release and reintegration into the
family and community.
24. To meet this obligation it demands that States Parties have in place procedural
guarantees. States Parties are urged to put in place policy, legislative, administrative
and judicial measures to ensure that the best interests of the children whose mothers
are in carceral institutions are safeguarded. Such measures, among others, should
include the following:
(a) As a general rule, States Parties should ensure that alternatives to custodial
sentences for expectant prisoners or those with children. In this regard, States
Parties should undertake both legislative and administrative measures to
ensure they give priority consideration to non-custodial measures when courts
sentence or decide on pre-trial measures for a child‟s sole or primary carer,
subject to the need to protect the public and the child and bearing in mind the
gravity of the offence.8 This necessarily entails that States Parties should
ensure that where protection of the public is not at issue, and subject to the
seriousness of the offence, an alternative to imprisonment should be applied;
8
A similar obligation is imposed on States by the UN General Assembly Resolution 63/241. See UN
General Assembly, Resolution: Rights of the Child, A/RES/ 63/241, para 47; and United Nations
Human Rights Council resolution 19/37 on the rights of the child, para 69.
11