3. The Applicant’s right to health pursuant article 25 of the UDHR and 11 of the ICESCR Section 20 (a) of the 1986 Liberian Constitution has not been violated 4. The Applicant’s right to dignity pursuant to Articles 22 of the UDHR and 9 of the ICESCR has not been violated. 5. That the Applicant’s right to equality before the law and freedom from discrimination pursuant to article Articles 2 of the ACHPR and 7 of the UDHR has not been violated. 6. That the Applicant’s right to property pursuant to articles 14 of the ACHPR and 20 of the Liberian Constitution has been violated by the Respondent. ORDERS: 1. The Respondent to calculate and pay to the Applicant his entitlement from 1997-2017 in accordance with the provision The Retirement Benefits Act. 2. The Respondent to calculate and pay to the Applicant as refund due to him for security and transport allowance based on the amount budgeted for same for other former members. 3. The Respondent to immediately restore the pension and other retirement benefits due to the Applicant as former Vice Chairman from the date of this judgment in accordance with The Retirement Benefit Act. 4. That the Respondent file a notice of compliance with above orders on or before 120 days from date of this judgement. 5. The Respondent to pay the Attorneys fees of $2,000 United States dollar as cost to the Applicant 33