172.
Whilst the above definition is useful, it fails to outline those categories of
actions that would constitute a violation under Article 5 of the African Charter.
To resolve this issue, the African Commission will in terms of Article 60 of the
African Charter rely on the jurisprudence of the Human Rights Committee which
has over the years, made a determination on whether the length of detention on
death row amounted to a violation of the prohibition against 'torture or cruel,
inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment'.50 In Randolph Barrett and
AC
HP
R
Clyde v. Jamaica,51 the Human Rights Committee held that in the review of
criminal convictions and sentences, an element of delay between the lawful
imposition of a sentence of death and the exhaustion of available remedies is
inherent in the review of the sentence; thus, even prolonged periods of detention
under a severe custodial regime on death row cannot generally be considered to
constitute cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment if the convicted person is
merely availing himself of appellate remedies.
173.
The African Commission is of the view that the computation of time as far as
the delays in executing the sentence is concern, will only start to run from the
time the High Court passed the death sentence and not from when the victim
was first arrested in 1993. The evidence before the African Commission indicates
that the ensuing delay in carrying out the death sentence was because the victim
had petitioned the Court of Appeal. The victim was partly responsible for these
delays and was exercising his rights to appeal. For this reasons the African
Commission finds that there is no violation of Article 5 in this regard.
174.
It was submitted by the Complainants that failure to publish the unsuccessful
outcome of the clemency petition and failure to give notice of the date and time
of execution amounts to cruel, inhuman and degrading punishment and
50
51
Under Article 7 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights
Communication 270/271/1988 (30 March 1992).
47
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents