constitute human rights violations, this Court recalls that it has ruled in this regard
in relation to Mexico in the Judgment of the case of Radilla Pacheco, a precedent
that has been repeated in the cases of Fernández Ortega and Rosendo Cantú.
Bearing in mind the foregoing and the points made by the State (supra para. 188),
for the purposes of this case, the Court deems sufficient to reiterate that:
[i]n a democratic State of law, the military criminal jurisdiction shall have a
restrictive and exceptional scope and be directed toward the protection of
special juridical interests, related to the tasks characteristic of the military
forces. Therefore, the Court has previously stated that only active soldiers
shall be prosecuted within the military jurisdiction for the perpetration of
crimes or offenses that based on their own nature threaten the juridical
rights of the military order itself. 302
Likewise, […] taking into account the nature of the crime and the juridical
right damaged, military criminal jurisdiction is not the competent jurisdiction
to investigate and, if applicable, prosecute and punish the perpetrators of
human rights violations; instead, the processing of those responsible always
corresponds to the ordinary justice system. In that sense, the Court, on
numerous occasions, has indicated that “[w]hen the military jurisdiction
assumes competence over a matter that should be heard by the ordinary
jurisdiction, it violates the right to a competent Court and, a fortiori, to due
process,” which is, at the same time, intimately related to the right to a fair
trial. The judge in charge of hearing a case shall be competent, as well as
independent and impartial. 303
Regarding situations that violate human rights of civilians, the military
jurisdiction cannot operate under any circumstance. 304
The Court [has] point[ed] out that when the military courts hear of acts that
constitute human rights violations against civilians they exercise jurisdiction
not only with regard to the defendant, who must necessarily be a person
with an active military status, but also with regard to the civilian victim, who
has the right to participate in the criminal proceedings, not only for the
purposes of the respective reparation of the damage but also to exercise his
right to the truth and to justice […]. Thus, the victims of human rights
violations and their families have the right to have those violations heard
and addressed by a competent Court, according to due process of law and
the right to a fair trial. The importance of the passive subject transcends the
military sphere of action, since juridical rights associated with the ordinary
regimen are involved. 305
198. To summarize, according to this Court’s case law, the military jurisdiction is
not competent to investigate and, if applicable, prosecute and punish the
perpetrators of alleged human rights violations; instead, those responsible must
always be tried by the ordinary justice system. This conclusion applies not only to
cases of torture, forced disappearance and rape, but to all human rights violations.
302
Case of Radilla Pacheco v. Mexico. Preliminary Objections, Merits, Reparations and Costs.
Judgment of November 23, 2009. Series C Nº 209 para. 272; Case of Fernández Ortega et al. v. Mexico,
supra note 39, para. 176; and Case of Rosendo Cantú et al. v. Mexico, supra note 30, para. 160.
303
Case of Radilla Pacheco v. Mexico, supra note 302, para. 273; Case of Fernández Ortega et al.
v. Mexico, supra note 39, para. 176; and Case of Rosendo Cantú et al. v. Mexico, supra note 30, para.
160.
304
Case of Radilla Pacheco v. Mexico, supra note 302, para. 274; Case of Fernández Ortega et al.
v. Mexico, supra note 39, para. 176; and Case of Rosendo Cantú et al. v. Mexico, supra note 30, para.
160.
305
Case of Radilla Pacheco v. Mexico, supra note 302, para. 275; Case of Fernández Ortega et al.
v. Mexico, supra note 39, para. 176; and Case of Rosendo Cantú et al. v. Mexico, supra note 30, para.
160.
75
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents