8
CONNORS v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT
40. Failure to comply with such a direction as soon as practicable, or reentry upon the land within three months, is a criminal offence. Local
authorities are able to apply to a magistrates’ court for an order authorising
them to remove caravans parked in contravention of such a direction
(section 78 of the 1994 Act).
41. Guidance issued by the Secretary of State dated 23 November 1994
(Circular 18/94) concerned the unauthorised camping by gypsies and the
power to give a direction to leave the land (CJPOA above). Paragraphs 6-9
required local authorities to adopt “a policy of toleration towards
unauthorised gypsy encampments”:
“6. ... Where gypsies are camped unlawfully on council land and are not causing a
level of nuisance which cannot be effectively controlled, an immediate forced eviction
might result in unauthorised camping on a site elsewhere in the area which could give
rise to greater nuisance. Accordingly, authorities should consider tolerating gypsies’
presence on the land for short periods and could examine the ways of minimising the
level of nuisance on such tolerated sites, for example by providing basic services for
gypsies e.g. toilets, a skip for refuse and a supply of drinking water. ...
8. Where gypsies are unlawfully camped on Government-owned land, it is for the
local authority, with the agreement of the land-owning Department, to take any
necessary steps to ensure that the encampment does not constitute a hazard to public
health. It will continue to be the policy of the Secretaries of State that Government
Departments should act in conformity with the advice that gypsies should not be
moved unnecessarily from unauthorised encampments when they are causing no
nuisance.
9. The Secretaries of State continue to consider that local authorities should not use
their powers to evict gypsies needlessly. They should use their powers in a humane
and compassionate fashion and primarily to reduce nuisance and to afford a higher
level of protection to private owners of land.”
42. Paragraphs 10-13 further require local authorities to consider their
obligations under other legislation before taking any decisions under
the 1994 Act. These obligations include their duties concerning pregnant
women and newly-born children, the welfare and education of children and
the housing of homeless persons. In a judgment of 22 September 1995
(R. v. Lincolnshire County Council, ex parte Atkinson, R. v. Wealden
District Council, ex parte Wales, and R. v. Wealden District Council, ex
parte Stratford, unreported), the High Court held that it would be an error of
law for any local authority to ignore those duties which must be considered
from the earliest stages.
3. Security of tenure on caravan sites
43. Occupiers of gypsy caravan sites run by a local authority receive
limited security of tenure pursuant to Part 1 of the 1968 Act. An occupier’s
contractual right can be determined by four-week’s notice and he may only
be evicted by court order. Local authorities are in addition required to have