ANGUELOVA v. BULGARIA JUDGMENT
11
[2.] Haematoma on the skin, spotted in a characteristic manner, and haematoma in
the soft tissue on the right side of the chest, along the anterior axillary line.
[3.] Surface skin grazes on the right side of the forehead and on the upper surface of
the left wrist with a limited haematoma in the soft tissue under the skin.
[4.] Haematoma of an oval shape and diameter of 0.5 cm on the mucous membrane
of the left lower lip.
[5.] Two strip-like surface bruises on the skin of typical shape, and haematoma in
the soft inner tissue, in the area of the wrist joint of the right hand.”
57. The experts further concluded:
“[The death was caused by] accumulated epidural cerebral haematoma on the lefthand side of the forehead, containing 110 ml of blood, followed by a cerebral oedema,
with wedging of the cerebellar tonsils into the foramen magnum; this oedema led to
the suppression and detachment of vital brain centres (those of breathing and heart
activity, which in turn caused a pulmonary oedema), and was the direct cause of
death.”
58. Addressing the question of the manner in which the injuries had
been inflicted, the experts stated:
“1. The injury in the area of the left orbital rim and the left eyeball and the epidural
haematoma were caused by a blow by, or against, a blunt object, or an object with a
blunt edge, [which had] a delineated [limited] and uneven surface. The blow was
sudden and sufficiently strong. It caused the fracture of the back wall of the left 'eye
bone' reaching its lower external side (furthermore, the skull bones are 0.2 cm thick);
2. [The injury to the right side of the chest was caused by] a blow by, or against, a
hard blunt object, or an object with a blunt edge, having a larger impact surface. The
marks in this area are spotted in a manner characteristic of an imprint of the victim's
clothes.
3. [The injuries to the right side of the forehead and to the wrists were the result of]
blows, or pressing, by or against sharp-edged objects. [The injury to the left part of the
lower lip was caused by] a blow by or against a hard blunt object having a delineated
[limited] surface.”
59. The experts also stated that in cases of epidural haematoma of the
kind Mr Zabchekov had suffered there was characteristically a lucid interval
of four to six hours during which no visible signs would be displayed,
except that
“the victim gradually becomes feeble, apathetic and sleepy, after which he falls into
a coma and dies – as happened in the present case (during the period between 1 a.m.
and 5 a.m. on 29 January 1996).”
The report concluded that Mr Zabchekov's death had been inevitable in
the absence of urgent surgical intervention.
60. The laboratory analysis found an alcohol level of 1.42‰ in
Mr Zabchekov's blood and 2.40‰ in his urine, corresponding to a medium
level of alcohol intoxication.