246
Mizan Law Review
Vol. 6 No.2, December 2012
In Manneh v The Gambia, the Court considered a case submitted against The
Gambia by legal counsels of Chief Ebrimah Manneh, a Gambian journalist who
was arrested without warrant by two officials of the National Intelligence
Agency of The Gambia.22 The officials did not give any reason for his arrest.
The plaintiff had been detained incommunicado. He had been detained for more
than a year without any criminal charge. The counsels for the plaintiff submitted
that the defendant violated Articles 4, 5, 6 and 7 of the African Charter. They
requested the Court to order the defendant to release the plaintiff and pay him
five million US dollars in damages. Although the defendant refused to make an
appearance, the Court heard witnesses and found that Articles 2, 6 and 7(1) of
the African Charter were violated.23 The Court also ordered the defendant to
pay US$ 100,000 to the plaintiff as damages.24
In Koraou v Niger, the Court considered a case of Hadijatou Mani Koraou, a
Nigerien woman who was sold at the age of 12 to a 46 years-old man as “the
fifth wife” called sadaka for the sum of 240,000 CFA Francs.25 The sale was
conducted according to wahiya practice which was prevalent in Niger and
consisted of “acquiring a young girl, generally under the conditions of servitude,
for her to serve both as domestic servant and concubine.”26 “The sadaka
generally carries out the domestic chores and caters for the ‘master’” who can
engage her in sexual relations at any time.27 The plaintiff had served her master
for nine years and obtained a certificate of emancipation from him in 2005.28
However, the ‘master’ refused to let the plaintiff free even after she obtained
certificate of emancipation.29 She escaped from her master and brought a case
against him which led to a judgment that she had never been married to her
master.30 While her civil case was being considered by appellate courts, the
plaintiff was prosecuted for bigamy upon the complaint of the master.31 The
plaintiff, her brother and her husband were sentenced to six months
imprisonment and a fine, and they were incarcerated until they were released on
appeal.32
22Manneh
v The Gambia (2008) AHRLR 171 (ECOWAS 2008), para 5.
para 41.
24 Ibid, para 44
25 Koraou vNiger (2008) AHRLR 182 (ECOWAS 2008), para 8.
26 Ibid, para 9.
27 Ibid, para 10.
28 Ibid, para 13.
29 Ibid, para 14.
30 Ibid, para 15-16.
31 Ibid, para 21.
32 Ibid, para 22-23.
23 Ibid,