000399
criminal complaint was aimed at ensuring that the violation of the rights guaranteed
by the Respondent State are recognised.
30. The Applicants submit that filing of a civil suit before the investigating judge would
require a decision from the Prosecutor General. Accordingly, in the absence of
such a decision, the process could not proceed and they were obliged to wait for
a response, which has been pending for five (5) years.
31.As regards continuation of the proceedings before the Labour Court, the Applicants
submit that the fact of bringing
a civil action does not preclude criminal
proceedings.
32. The Applicants allege that the time between the filing of the criminal complaint and
the date of referral of the case to the Court attest to the undue delay in processing
appeals. This renders inapplicable the requirement of exhaustion of local remedies
set out in Rule 40(5) of the Rules and Article 56(5) of the Charter.
33.The issue to be addressed is whether there is a remedy in the Respondent State's
judicial system which the Applicants ought to have pursued to address the delay
of the Prosecutor General's decision over their complaint.
34.1n this regard, the Court recalls that in the matter of Diakitd Couple v. Republic of
Malia,
il held that under Article
625 of the Mali Code of Criminal Procedure, "the
petitioners had at least the opportunity to appeal directly to the investigating judge
by filing a civil suit."
35. The Court found in that case that referral to the investigating judge was an effective
and satisfactory remedy under Article 90 of the Mali Code of Criminal Procedure,
which provides that '"l-he investigating judge shall, in accordance with the law , take all such
4 Application No. 009/2016. Judgment
ot 281912017 (Admissibility), Diakite Couple
(hereinafter referred lo as Diakite Couple v. Mali (Admissibility),), g. a5.
5
Anyone who claims to be wronged by a crime or an offense may, by filing a complain
before the competent investigating judge."
v.
10
r1\{
*[2
Republic of Mali
ring a civil action
"