the second set of figures gave a value of 14,893.9million lire for the assets,
and 15,775.2 million lire for the liabilities. The auditors stated in their
covering letter to Raytheon accountants that
"The adjustments made by the company in preparing the above
mentioned balance sheet and statement of income and accumulated
losses have not, at the date of this report, been recorded in the books,
essentially for tax reasons. Accordingly, the accompanying financial
statements are not in agreement with the company's books of
account."
Arnong the "Notes on Financial Statements" attached to the accounts by
the auditors was the following :
"10. The adjusted accumulated losses at September 30, 1967
exceeded the total of the paid up capital stock, capital reserve and
Stockholders subscription account by an amount of 881.3 million
lire. Should this become 'officially' the case (e.g. should the adjustments made in arriving at this total of accumulated losses be entered
in the company's books of account), under Articles 2447 and 2448 of
the Italian Civil Code the directors would be obliged to convene a
Stockholders' Meeting forthwith to take measures either to cover the
losses by providing new capital or to put the company into liquidation."
The auditors also expressed reservations on two other items totalling
1,168.5 million lire.
20. I h e officials of Raytheon and ELSI were nevertheless advised by
their Italian counsel in March 1968 that "ELSI's capital, after taking into
account losses to date at that time, was well in excess of the minimum
statutory requirement" (1 million lire) under Articles 2447 and 2448 of the
Italian Civil Code, which provide that if action is not taken to restore the
capital to the required minimum, the company is dissolved as a matter of
law. In the view of ELSI's counsel, "it was therefore possible under Italian
law for ELSI's shareholders to plan an orderly liquidation of the company".
21. Throughout this Judgment this phrase "orderly liquidation" is used
solely in the sense in which it was employed by the officers of ELSI and by
the representatives of the United States, i.e., to denote the operation
planned in 1967-1968by ELSI's management for the sale of the business
or of its assets, en bloc or separately, and the discharge of ELSI's debts,
fully or othenvise, out of the proceeds, the whole operation being under
the control of ELSI's own management.
22. According to the United States, the chief objectives in the planned
orderly liquidation were to conserve the assets and preserve as many of the