I:tCO'f) AC H PR
•
>.
.
.
"
African Commission on
Human and Peoples' Rights
Human Rights our
Collective nosponsibility
that should be drawn to the attention of the AU Assembly. To exercise such a
discretion, the Commission must act judiciously based on the current situation.
273. By the very nature of the wording of Article 58(1),the Commission is required
to act in a certain way upon the occurrence of a specified set of circumstances.
Specifically, Article 58(1) directs the Commission to draw the attention of the AU
Assembly to 'special cases' which reveal a 'series' of 'serious and massive
violations' of human and peoples' rights.
274. Indeed, the allegations of massive or serious violations of several provisions of
the African Charter contained in this Communication are quite concerning. The
neglect, failure or refusal of the Respondent State to respond-to the seriousness of
the accusations warrant that the nature of the human rights violations found in
this case be better understood.
275. However, after careful deliberations, the Commission is of th~ opinion that the
issues for which the Complainants had sought a referral to the AU Assembly under
Article 58 of the African Charter have been overtaken by events and that it is no
longer necessary to do so. In the lightof this, the Commission declines the
Complainants' request to draw the attention of the AU Assembly to the issue of
massive and serious violations in South Kordofan and Blue Nile under Article 58
of the African Charter.
276. The Complainants also prayed the Commission to re-iterate its request to the
Respondent State for provisional measures-to prevent irreparable harm to civilians
in accordance with Rule 98. However, the Complainants have not provided any
information update to suggest that the harms alleged in 2011 are currently
ongoing: The essence of "provisional" measures is to prevent the occurrence of
irreparable harm pending when a decision is made.
277. Considering the length of time that has passed since the alleged violations
occurred and now, it is the Commission's reasoned consideration it is not relevant
to reiterate the Provisional Measures issued to the Respondent State.
278.
56
An Organ Qf Ihe
AfriGan ((-':~~)
Union
,I<x,"~
https:/achpr.au.inVO
0 a