KURT JUDGMENT OF 25 MAY 1998
5
villagers were told that they had a week to evacuate the village. The
villagers fled to Bismil, many as they were homeless, and those who were
not being too scared to remain.
15. According to the applicant, around noon on 24 November 1993,
when the villagers had been gathered by the soldiers in the schoolyard, the
soldiers were looking for her son, Üzeyir, who was not in the schoolyard.
He was hiding in the house of his aunt Mevlüde (see paragraph 14 above).
When the soldiers asked Aynur Kurt, his daughter, where her father was,
Aynur told them he was at his aunt’s house. The soldiers went to Mevlüde’s
house with Davut Kurt, another of the applicant’s sons, and took Üzeyir
from the house. Üzeyir spent the night of 24–25 November 1993 with
soldiers in the house of Hasan Kılıç.
On the morning of 25 November 1993, the applicant received a message
from a child that Üzeyir wanted some cigarettes. The applicant took
cigarettes and found Üzeyir in front of Hasan Kılıç’s house surrounded by
about ten soldiers and five to six village guards. She saw bruises and
swelling on his face as though he had been beaten. Üzeyir told her that he
was cold. She returned with his jacket and socks. The soldiers did not allow
her to stay so she left. This was the last time she saw Üzeyir. The applicant
maintains that there is no evidence that he was seen elsewhere after this
time.
16. On 30 November 1993 the applicant applied to the Bismil public
prosecutor, Ridvan Yıldırım, to find out information on the whereabouts of
her son. On the same day, she received a response from Captain Izzet Cural
at the provincial gendarmerie headquarters stating that it was supposed that
Üzeyir had been kidnapped by the PKK (the Kurdish Workers’ Party).
Captain Cural, who had proposed the plan for the operation in the village,
replied in identical terms on 4 December 1993. The district gendarmerie
commander noted on the bottom of the applicant’s petition of 30 November
that Üzeyir had not been taken into custody and that he had been kidnapped
by the PKK.
17. On 14 December 1993 the applicant applied to the National Security
Court in Diyarbakır which replied that he was not in their custody records.
On 15 December 1993 she contacted the Bismil public prosecutor again but
was referred to the gendarmerie. Finally, on 24 December 1993 the
applicant approached the Diyarbakır Human Rights Association for help
and made a statement on the circumstances surrounding her son’s
disappearance.
18. On 28 February 1994 Davut Karakoç (Üzeyir’s cousin), Arap Kurt
(Üzeyir’s uncle and muhtar of the village) and Mehmet Kurt (another of
Üzeyir’s cousins) were taken to the gendarmerie and questioned about what
they knew of “Üzeyir Kurt who was abducted by representatives of the PKK
terrorist organisation”. On 21 March 1994 the Bismil public prosecutor
issued a decision of non-jurisdiction on the grounds that a crime had been
committed by the PKK.