353. Thirdly, the Applicant State avers that the question of lis pendens does not
arise in the instant case, since under Rule 37(1) of the Rules, lis pendens
can only be invoked where the same case is pending before the Court and
the Commission. Furthermore, it observes that, in his dissenting opinion in
Tike Mwambipile and Equality Now v. United Republic of Tanzania, Judge
Ben Achour stressed that “the principle (of litis pendence), which is highly
controversial, cannot be applied whenever a case is pending before another
court or human rights body”.
354. The Applicant State points out that if the Court decides to disregard the
objection, it must comply with substantive requirements, namely, similarity
of the parties and of the subject matter of the cases brought before at least
two courts which, moreover, must be of the same order, having regard to
the nature of their tasks and their jurisdiction, which is not the situation in
the instant case. In this regard, it cites the judgment of the ICJ in the matter
of Certain German Interests in Polish Upper Silesia (Germany v. Poland).
355. In this respect, the Applicant State explains that the Court is an international
court with jurisdiction over the protection of human rights in Africa, whereas
the EACJ is a court whose jurisdiction, mainly relating to the interpretation
and application of Community law, is confined to one region in Africa.
356. At the hearing, the Applicant State reiterated the content of its submissions.
It asserted that Rule 50(2)(g) of the Rules could not be interpreted differently
from the Court's established jurisprudence. It further submitted that the
present Application is different from proceedings before the EACJ, and that,
in any event, lis pendens is not a ground for this Court declaring an
application inadmissible.
*
357. In its Response, the Respondent State argues that the Applicant’s assertion
that lis pendens has no normative basis in the African human rights
protection system, nor in any practice of the instant Court, since it is a
79
اختر الفقرة المستهدفة3
الاتصال بفقرة
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
أضف إلى جدول المحتويات