SELÇUK AND ASKER JUDGMENT OF 24 APRIL 1998
9
The administration shall be liable to indemnify any damage caused by its own acts
and measures.”
34. The above provision is not subject to any restrictions even in a state
of emergency or war. The latter requirement of the provision does not
necessarily require proof of the existence of any fault on the part of the
administration, whose responsibility is of an absolute, objective nature,
based on a concept of collective liability and referred to as the theory of
“social risk”. Thus the administration may indemnify people who have
suffered damage from acts committed by unknown or terrorist authors when
the State may be said to have failed in its duty to maintain public order and
safety, or in its duty to safeguard individual life and property.
35. The principle of administrative liability is reflected in the additional
section 1 of Law no. 2935 of 25 October 1983 on the State of Emergency,
which provides:
“... actions for compensation in relation to the exercise of the powers conferred by
this Law are to be brought against the administration before the administrative courts.”
B. Criminal responsibility
36. The Turkish Criminal Code makes it a criminal offence:
– to deprive an individual unlawfully of his or her liberty (Article 179
generally, Article 181 in respect of civil servants),
– to oblige an individual through force or threats to commit or not to
commit an act (Article 188),
– to issue threats (Article 191),
– to make an unlawful search of an individual’s home (Articles 193 and
194),
– to commit arson (Articles 369, 370, 371, 372), or aggravated arson if
human life is endangered (Article 382),
– to commit arson unintentionally by carelessness, negligence or
inexperience (Article 383), or
– to damage another’s property intentionally (Articles 526 et seq.).
37. For all these offences complaints may be lodged, pursuant to
Articles 151 and 153 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, with the public
prosecutor or the local administrative authorities. The public prosecutor and
the police have a duty to investigate crimes reported to them, the former
deciding whether a prosecution should be initiated, pursuant to Article 148
of the Code of Criminal Procedure. A complainant may appeal against the
decision of the public prosecutor not to institute criminal proceedings.