17
SOERING v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT
or other arbitrary factor (see paragraph 52 above) is reviewed without
regard to whether objection was made at trial (see Briley v. Bass, loc. cit.).
56. The average time between trial and execution in Virginia, calculated
on the basis of the seven executions which have taken place since 1977, is
six to eight years. The delays are primarily due to a strategy by convicted
prisoners to prolong the appeal proceedings as much as possible. The
United States Supreme Court has not as yet considered or ruled on the
"death row phenomenon" and in particular whether it falls foul of the
prohibition of "cruel and unusual punishment" under the Eighth
Amendment to the Constitution of the United States.
E. Legal assistance for appeals
57. All prisoners who have been sentenced to death have individual
lawyers to represent them, whether privately recruited or court-appointed.
On the other hand, there is no statutory provision expressly mandating legal
assistance to be made available to the indigent prisoner to file habeas corpus
petitions. However, it has recently been affirmed by a United States Court
of Appeal that the Commonwealth of Virginia is required to provide
indigent prisoners who have been sentenced to death with the assistance of
lawyers to pursue challenges to their death sentences in State habeas corpus
actions (Giarratano v. Murray, 847 F.2d 1118 (4th Circuit 1988) (en banc) case currently pending before the United States Supreme Court). In Federal
habeas corpus and certiorari proceedings case-law does not impose the same
obligation (ibid., p. 1122, column 1), for the reason that the Federal courts
would have available the appellate briefs, a transcript and State court
opinion (in certiorari proceedings) and the briefs of counsel, a transcript and
opinion (in habeas corpus proceedings).
Virginia inmates also have access to legal information and assistance in
the form of law libraries and institutional attorneys. The institutional
attorneys are available to assist inmates in "any legal matter relating to their
incarceration" (Virginia Code, section 53.1-40), including the drafting of
habeas corpus petitions and motions for appointment of counsel for the
inmates to file.
A prisoner is not obliged to proceed with counsel, and he may litigate in
both State and Federal courts pro se. However, no Virginia prisoner under
sentence of death in contemporary times has ever been unrepresented during
his trial, appeal or habeas corpus proceedings. Nor has any such prisoner
faced execution without counsel.
F. Authorities involved in the death penalty procedure
58. A Commonwealth’s Attorney for each county in Virginia is elected
every four years (Article VII(4) of the Constitution of Virginia). His