5
MARCKX v. BELGIUM JUDGMENT
Proceedings to establish maternal affiliation (action en recherche de
maternité) may be instituted by the child within five years from his
attainment of majority or, whilst he is still a minor, by his legal
representative with the consent of the family council (Articles 341a-341c of
the Civil Code).
2. Effects of the establishment of maternal affiliation
15. The establishment of the maternal affiliation of an "illegitimate" child
has limited effects as regards both the extent of his family relationships and
the rights of the child and his mother in the matter of inheritance on
intestacy and voluntary dispositions.
a. The extent of family relationships
16. In the context of the maternal affiliation of an "illegitimate" child,
Belgian legislation does not employ the concepts of "family" and "relative".
Even once such affiliation has been established, it in principle creates a
legal bond with the mother alone. The child does not become a member of
his mother’s family. The law excludes it from that family as regards
inheritance rights on intestacy (see paragraph 17 below). Furthermore, if the
child’s parents are dead or under an incapacity, he cannot marry, before
attaining the age of twenty-one, without consent which has to be given by
his guardian (Article 159 of the Civil Code) and not, as is the case for a
"legitimate" child, by his grandparents (Article 150); the law does not
expressly create any maintenance obligations, etc., between the child and
his grandparents. However, certain texts make provision for exceptions, for
example as regards the impediments to marriage (Articles 161 and 162).
According to a judgment of 22 September 1966 of the Belgian Court of
Cassation (Pasicrisie I, 1967, pp 78-79), these texts "place the bonds
existing between an illegitimate child and his grandparents on a legal
footing based on the affection, respect and devotion that are the
consequence of consanguinity ... (which) creates an obligation for the
ascendants to take an interest in their descendants and, as a corollary, gives
them the right, whenever this is not excluded by the law, to know and
protect them and exercise over them the influence dictated by affection and
devotion". The Court of Cassation deduced from this that grandparents were
entitled to a right of access to the child.
(b) Rights of a child born out of wedlock and of his mother in the matter of
inheritance on intestacy and voluntary dispositions
17. A recognised "illegitimate" child’s rights of inheritance on intestacy
are less than those of a "legitimate" child. As appears from Articles 338,
724, 756 to 758, 760, 761, 769 to 773 and 913 of the Civil Code, a
recognised "illegitimate" child does not have, in the estate of his parent who
dies intestate, the status of heir but solely that of "exceptional heir"