2
3.
According to the facts described by the Commission, the State arbitrarily
deprived Mr. Ivcher Bronstein, naturalized Peruvian citizen, majority shareholder,
Director and President of Channel 2-Frecuencia Latina (hereinafter “Channel 2”, “the
Channel” or “Frecuencia Latina”) of the Peruvian television network of his nationality
title, in order to remove him from the editorial control of the said channel and
restrict his freedom of expression, which he manifested by denouncing grave
violations of human rights and acts of corruption.
4.
The Commission therefore requested the Court to call on Peru to restore and
guarantee to Mr. Ivcher the enjoyment of all his rights and, in particular that it
should:
a.
Order that Mr. Ivcher Bronstein’s Peruvian nationality title be reinstated and
that the full and unconditional recognition of his Peruvian nationality be restored, with all
attendant rights and prerogatives.
b.
Order that Mr. Ivcher Bronstein’s enjoyment and exercise of his right to own
shares in Compañía Latinoamericana de Radiodifusión S.A. be restored along with all his
prerogatives as a shareholder in and administrator of that company.
c.
Order that Peru must guarantee Mr. Ivcher Bronstein’s enjoyment and exercise
[of] his right to freedom of expression and, in particular, that the acts of harassment
and persecution against him, including the acts against his family and his company
[should] cease.
d.
Order that the Peruvian State must adopt the necessary legislative and
administrative measures to make full reparation and compensate Mr. Ivcher Bronstein
for all the material and moral damages that the acts of its administrative and judicial
organs have caused him.
The Commission also petitioned the Court to order the State to adopt the necessary
legislative and administrative measures to avoid a recurrence of events of this
nature, and to investigate and punish those responsible for the violations of the
fundamental rights of Mr. Ivcher Bronstein. Lastly, the Commission requested that
the State be ordered to pay the costs and reimburse the expenses incurred by the
alleged victim in litigating this case, in both the domestic courts and the interAmerican system, including reasonable fees for his representatives.
II
COMPETENCE OF THE COURT
5.
The Court is competent to hear the instant case. Peru has been a State Party
to the American Convention since July 28, 1978, and recognized the obligatory
jurisdiction of the Court on January 21, 1981.
III
PROCEDURE BEFORE THE COMMISSION
6.
On June 9, 1997, the Peruvian Congressman, Javier Díez Canseco, advised
the Commission that Mr. Ivcher Bronstein might possibly be deprived of his Peruvian
nationality. On July 16, 1997, the Dean of the Lima Bar Association, Vladimir Paz de
la Barra, filed a petition with the Commission alleging that the State had revoked Mr.
Ivcher’s Peruvian citizenship.