1;,..�1 6�!:LE�
�<iu:ff() •
Human and Peoples' Rights
Human Rights our
Collective Responsibility
107. The Complainant submits that the Supreme Court acted contrary to the
equality of arms principle in that its interpretation discriminates between a
plaintiff and a defendant as the latter is not bound to retain services of an attorney
to defend or resist an action.
108. These facts, so the complaint contends, amount to violations of articles 3, 7 and
26 of the Charter and this is what the Commission will determine.
109. In support to his claims, the Complain cites a number of statutory provisions,
notably Section 17, 36, 56 and 198 of the Courts Act, Rule 3 of the Supreme Court
Rules 2000, Rule 1, 2 and 3 of the Legal Fees and Costs Rules 2000. The
Complainant also adduces a number of documentary evidence.
110. In substance, the Complainant claims the right to litigate in person or in other
words the right to access to the courts and to defend himself without retaining the
services of an attorney, in order to seek the re-opening of both the criminal matter
which led to his conviction and incarceration for six months and the disciplinary
proceedings that led to his disbarment.
Failure by the Respondent State to make observations on the merits
111. By Note Verbale Ref: ACHPR/COMM/459/13/ MAUR/920/22 dated 26
September 2022, the Commission informed the Respondent State that the
Complainant had confirmed that his submissions in the original complaint and the
responses to the Respondent State adequately address the merits of the
communication and therefore stands as his submissions on the merits. The
Commission further invited the Respondent State to submit its written
observations on the Complainant's submissions on the merits on the
abovementioned communication within sixty (60) days of receipt of the
notification. To this date, the Commission has not received any submissions on
merits from the Respondent State.
112. On several occasions, the Commission has made it clear that where allegations
of violations of provisions of the African Charter go uncontested
Government concerned, the Commission must decide on the facts pr
Complainant and treat those facts as given, as was determined
\..,,.,..1..
Africanr ''
Union �
Page 25 of 45
African Commission on Human an
31 Bijilo Annex Layout, Korn
West Coa
Phone: (220) 230 4361 Fa
Email: au-banjul
https:/achpr.au.int/00 a