GÜLEÇ JUDGMENT OF 27 JULY 1998
6
In the course of these events Ahmet Güleç, a senior-high-school pupil,
was killed on the spot by a shot fired by armed troublemakers who had
mingled with the demonstrators. A number of civilians were wounded and
taken to the public hospital in Cizre. Ekrem Oruç died in hospital. Seven
soldiers were injured by flying stones. Some fifty men and seventeen
women who had taken part in the unauthorised demonstration were taken
into police custody. Twenty-nine spent cartridges from Kalashnikov-type
weapons were found at the scene of the demonstration.
(d)
Report on the medical examination and autopsy performed on Ahmet Güleç
18. “Medical examination
... The body was stripped.
At the mid-point of the right axillary line towards the victim’s back there was a
wound 1 cm in diameter caused by a bullet fired from some distance. The exit wound
measures 2 cm in diameter and is 20 cm lower, about 10 cm in from the outside of the
groin. Approximately 5 cm below the entry wound on the same right axillary line
there is a further wound caused by a bullet fragment measuring 1 cm by 1.5 cm.
The body was still warm when the examination commenced. Rigor mortis had not
set in and there was no cyanosis. It was concluded from this that death had occurred
approximately one hour earlier.
... Two expert opinions were requested. These confirmed the public prosecutor’s
finding (see above), that is that there is no exit wound relating to the bullet fragment
which entered through the middle of the thorax, underneath the right arm. Further,
they confirmed that, 5 cm above the point of impact of the fragment, there is an entry
wound caused by a bullet striking at an oblique angle, with an exit wound on the same
trajectory. Since neither the bullet nor the fragments touched any vital organ, the
experts recommended that a full autopsy be carried out in order to determine the
precise cause of death.”
“Autopsy
The ribcage and abdominal cavity were opened according to the usual procedures. A
large quantity of accumulated blood was observed in the thoracic cavity.
Approximately 3 litres of blood were pumped out. The left lung had been lacerated by
the bullet fragment which, as noted above, struck the victim at the mid-point of the
right axillary line. The bullet whose entry and exit wounds were identified and whose
trajectory did not touch any vital organ could not have caused death. We conclude that
death was caused by the bullet fragment which struck the victim at the mid-point of
the right axillary line; this followed a horizontal trajectory, hitting the left lung and
causing death by internal haemorrhaging and hypovolaemic shock. In the course of the
full autopsy, the bullet fragment which struck the left lung was found in the left armpit
and was placed under seal as an exhibit...”