Practice and Procedures clearly provide for a hearing in judicial review
and conservatory or interim orders;
10. On the merits, the Applicant submits that:
a. The Applicants before the Commission had locus standi in accordance with the
actio popularis doctrine adopted by the Commission in its jurisprudence. In any
event, two of the complainants before the Commission are NGOs registered in
Kenya, one of which works specifically to promote the rights of the Ogieks;
b. The Commission observed the audi alterem partem principle by serving the
complaint before it on the Respondent, which made submissions on admissibility,
and handed the request for provisional measures it issued to the Respondent’s
representative during its 50th Ordinary Session.
c. The application before the Court is not pending before the Commission as the
entire matter has been referred to the Court in terms of Article 5(1)(a) of the
Protocol and Rule 33(1)(a) of the Rules f Court and Rule 118(2) and (3) of the
Rules of Procedure of Commission. In any event Article 4(1) of the Protocol and
Rule 123 of the Commission’s Rules of Procedure preclude the two institutions
considering the same matter simultaneously.
d. While the Commission could have drawn the matter to the attention of the
Assembly of Heads of State in terms of Article 58 of the Charter, it was not
obliged to do so, as it had the discretion to refer the matter to the Court in
accordance with the complementary protective mandate of the two institutions
prescribed in Article 2 of the Protocol.
e. And finally, while the new Constitution of Kenya recognizes communal ownership
of land; guarantees the right to culture and the right to practice religion; and
imposes an obligation on the State to enact legislation that ensures
compensation and royalties for the Ogieks’ culture and heritage, this remains a
potential remedy as the necessary legislative, regulatory and institutional
framework has not yet been put in place. In any event the violations arose under
the old constitution and in a time frame which renders the new constitutional
provisions irrelevant and renders it incapable of providing redress to the Ogieks.