'f) 6�!,jsiEfi
i-.CHP!i
f,
Human s;ghrs ou,
Human and Peoples' Rights
Collective Responsibility
legal assistance, and procedural mechanisms that enable individuals to present
their cases before a competent judicial body.
mm,, •
174.
The Commission's recognition of these obligations underscores the
comprehensive nature of the right to sound justice. It goes beyond mere access
to a court and encompasses the guarantee of a fair trial. By emphasizing the
importance of providing individuals with both an accessible and appropriate
court and the opportunity to have their cause heard fairly, the Commission
ensures that justice is effectively served. This approach reinforces the principles
of fairness, equality, and the rule of law, which are fundamental to realizing
the right to sound justice as enshrined in Article 7 of the African Charter.
1 75.
The Commission underscores that the right to a timely and impartial
trial holds immense significance in upholding the fairness and integrity of legal
proceedings. It encompasses two crucial elements: timeliness and impartiality,
essential for ensuring justice. It is important to emphasize that no
circumstances can justify the denial of the right to be brought before a court, as
it serves as a foundational principle for the realization of a fair trial.
1 76.
In the case of Purohit v The Gambia, the Commission established a
precedent that individuals subjected to detention should, at the very least, have
the opportunity to challenge the lawfulness of their detention before competent
jurisdictions.55 This ruling highlights the fundamental principle that those
detained must be granted the right to contest their deprivation of liberty and
have their cases reviewed by independent and competent courts.
1 77.
By recognizing the significance of timely access to justice and the
requirement of impartiality, the Commission reaffirms the essential nature of
these elements in upholding the principles of fairness, equality, and the rule of
law. Upholding the right to a timely and impartial trial ensures that individuals
have the necessary safeguards to contest their detention and have their cases
heard by competent and independent courts. This approach is vital for
safeguarding individual rights, promoting transparency and accountability,
and maintaining public trust in the justice system.
Upon thorough examination of the facts and analysis, it is evident that
178.
the failure to present the Complainant before a court during his 71 to 78 da s
of detention gives rise to significant concerns regarding the Respon
compliance with the requirement of a timely trial. It is crucial to en}'Jmt�
55 Communication 241/2001 Purohit and Moore v. The Gambia (May 2003) ACHPR.
41
An OrQan of U>e
AfriGan ( · �'\
nton ' ,cu:)
u
African Commis
31 Bijilo An
r;S;;:i:i.iiiiiH.::,,i;
mbia
Phone: (220) 230 4361 Fax: (220) 441 OS 04
Email: au-banjul@africa-union.org
https:/achpr au.int/0 0 a