00135?
against three criteria: first, it must be provided by law; second,
it must be
imposed by a competent court; and, third, it must abide by due process.
'105.
The Court notes, with respect to the requirement of legality, that the
mandatory imposition of the death sentence is provided for in Section 197 of
the Penal Code of Tanzania. The requirement that the penalty should be
provided for in the law is thus met.
106.
Regarding the requirement of the death sentence being passed by a
competent court following due process, the Court notes that the Applicants'
contention is not that the courts of the Respondent State lacked jurisdiction to
conduct the processes that led to the imposition of the death penalty. Their
submission is rather that the High Court could impose the death sentence only
because it was provided for in the law as mandatory without any discretion of
the judicial officer.
107.
As to whether the mandatory imposition of the death penalty meets the
requirement of due process, this Court observes that, by a joint reading of
Articles 1,7(1), and 26 of the Charter,2s due process does not only encompass
procedural rights, strictly speaking, such as the rights to have one's cause
heard, to appeal, and to defence but also extends to the sentencing process. lt
is for this reason that any penalty must be imposed by a tribunal that
is
independent in the sense that it retains full discretion in determining matters of
fact and law.
108. ln the present case, this Court, firstly, notes that the mandatory
imposition
of the death penalty as provided for in Section 197 of
the
Respondent State's Penal Code is framed as follows: "A person convicted of
murder shall be sentenced to death". The automatic and mechanical application
of this provision in cases of murder is confirmed by the wording of the sentence
2s
Article 26 of the Charter reads: "States parties to the present Charter shall have the duty to guarantee
the independence of the Courts and shall allow the establishment and improvement of appropriate
national institutions entrusted with the promotion and protection of the rights and freedoms guaranteed
by the present Charter."
30
@-