Communication 431/12 – Thomas Kwoyelo v. Uganda
laws or procedures to vindicate itself from its treaty obligations. 48 The
domestication of the Rome Statute, while a commendable measure, cannot justify
the differential treatment. The domestication of the Statute is a measure that
facilitates domestic application and enforcement of the provisions of the Rome
Statute, not a measure marking the commencement of the obligations of a state
under the Statute.
192.
Accordingly, since Uganda assumed such obligations under the Rome Statute
since 2002, that is, the year it ratified the Statute, the DPP should have also refused
the amnesty applications of the two Brigadiers in order to try them for serious
violations of human rights. But the DPP did not try the two Brigadiers, therefore,
the enactment of the Rome Statute Act is not a convincing reason to justify the
differential treatment.
193.
The third ground upon which the Respondent State justifies or explains its
differential treatment is that at the time of the Victim’s arrest in 2009 many people
were ready and willing to testify against him as a result of the establishment of
relative peace in Northern Uganda and the return of those people that were
sheltered in IDP camps. And the Respondent argues that it was not possible to use
such witness evidence to prosecute those who had already been granted amnesty
in the past owing to lack of witness evidence.
194.
However, the Respondent has not proffered any proof showing that
investigations were indeed conducted against some amnesty applicants suspected
of committing serious human rights violations but were closed for lack of witness
evidence. No report of police investigation or report by the DPP were adduced to
such effect. In the absence of such proof, the Commission is left with no option but
to find that the availability or otherwise of witnesses is not persuasive enough to
justify differential treatment.
48
Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties of 1969, Article 27.
52
62nd Ordinary Session, 25 April – 9 July 2018
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents