10
TSALIKIDIS AND OTHERS v. GREECE JUDGMENT
II. RELEVANT DOMESTIC LAW
A. Code of Criminal Procedure
34. The relevant articles of the Code of Criminal Procedure as in force at
the material time read as follows:
Article 36
Criminal proceedings initiated of the authorities’ own motion
“When a criminal complaint or a petition is not necessary, criminal prosecution may
be initiated of the authorities’ own motion following a report, a complaint or any other
information indicating that an offence has been committed.”
Article 43
Initiation of criminal proceedings
“1. A public prosecutor, upon receiving a complaint or a report, shall initiate
criminal proceedings by ordering a preliminary investigation or a main investigation
or, wherever applicable, by referring the case to the court by directly summoning the
accused person. However in cases of felonies or misdemeanors punishable with prison
sentences of at least three months, except for: a) ..., b) ..., c) ..., d) ..., and e) ... ,
criminal proceedings shall be initiated only upon the completion of a preliminary
investigation, or preliminary operations under article 243 § 2 resulting in sufficient
indications for initiating criminal proceedings ...
2. If the criminal complaint or report has no legal basis, or is manifestly unfounded
on its merits, or is not subject to judicial assessment, the public prosecutor at the
Court of First Instance shall archive it and submit a copy to the public prosecutor at
the Court of Appeal, citing his reasons for deciding not to initiate criminal
proceedings. The same actions shall be taken if, following a preliminary examination
or preliminary measures pursuant to Article 243 § 2 or a sworn administrative
investigation, the public prosecutor considers that there is not sufficient evidence to
initiate criminal proceedings. The public prosecutor at the Court of Appeal has the
right: a) in the case of the first subparagraph, to order a preliminary examination to be
conducted by the public prosecutor at the Court of First Instance if the offence is a
felony or a misdemeanour falling under the jurisdiction of the three-member
Misdemeanour Court, or to order the initiation of criminal proceedings for the other
offences; b) in the case of the second subparagraph, to order the initiation of criminal
proceedings.
3. The competent public prosecutor shall take the case file out of the archive again
only if new facts or evidence are referred to or emerge which, in his view, justify a
re-examination of the case ...”
Article 46
Criminal complaint filed by the victim
“1. If the victim of a punishable offence wishes to request initiation of criminal
proceedings, he or she shall file a criminal complaint (έγκληση) in accordance with
Article 42 §§ 2, 3 and 4 ...”