(~;I)ACHPR
I .~. African
an~._
Commission on
Human and Peoples' Rights
Human Rights our
Collective Responsibility
residence to be reasonably justified, the onus is on the Respondent State to show
that the limitation on the right, seeks to achieve a legitimate aim, is absolutely
necessary and strictly proportional. This onus has neither been rebutted nor
dispensed with by the Respondent State in this case.
168.
In the Sudan Human Rights Organisation case, the Commission held that:
Freedom of movement and residence are two sides of the same coin. States therefore
have a dUll) to ensure that the exercise of these rights is not subjected to arbitrary
restrictions. Restrictions on the enjoyment of these rights should. be proportionate and
necessan) to respond to a specific public need or pursue a legitimate aim. Under
international law, it is the dUll) of States to take all measures to avoid conditions which
might lead to displacement and thus impact the enjoyment of freedom of movement and
residences?
169. In General Comment No.5 on the African Charter on Human and Peoples I Rights: The
Right to Freedom of Movement and Residence (Article 12(1)),the Commission clarifies
that the right to freedom of movement imposes a duty on the State not to interfere
with the enjoyment of the free movement .of individuals. This duty includes not
imposing or allowing impediments, whether social constructed or politically
driven, in the lawful exercise of the freedom to choose residence.P The
Commission also noted that, by the very nature of the territorial component of
Article 12, State Parties are required to protect the right to freedom of movement
of every person primarily within their borders, which includes every political and
administrative subdivisions of States.t?
170. Similarly, under Principle 5 of the UN Guiding Principles on Internal Displacement,
national authorities and international actors are required to adhere to international
law in relation to their obligations to respect and ensure respect for human rights
and humanitarian law, in order to prevent or avoid situations that can lead to
internal displacement. 60
An Orgun of the
African f~t))
Union ,.,l
https:/achpr.au.inVO
0 a