KURT JUDGMENT OF 25 MAY 1998
15
who have suffered damage from acts committed by unknown or terrorist
authors when the State may be said to have failed in its duty to maintain
public order and safety, or in its duty to safeguard individual life and
property.
B. Criminal law and procedure
58. The Turkish Criminal Code makes it a criminal offence
– to deprive an individual unlawfully of his or her liberty (Article 179
generally, Article 181 in respect of civil servants),
– to issue threats (Article 191),
– to subject an individual to torture or ill-treatment (Articles 243 and
245).
In respect of all these offences complaints may be lodged, pursuant to
Articles 151 and 153 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, with the public
prosecutor or the local administrative authorities. The public prosecutor and
the police have a duty to investigate crimes reported to them, the former
deciding whether a prosecution should be initiated, pursuant to Article 148
of the Code of Criminal Procedure. A complainant may appeal against the
decision of the public prosecutor not to institute criminal proceedings.
59. Generally, if the alleged author of a crime is a State official or civil
servant, permission to prosecute must be obtained from local administrative
councils (the Executive Committee of the Provincial Assembly). The local
council decisions may be appealed to the Supreme Administrative Court; a
refusal to prosecute is subject to an automatic appeal of this kind. If the
offender is a member of the armed forces, he would fall under the
jurisdiction of the military courts and would be tried in accordance with the
provisions of Article 152 of the Military Criminal Code.
C. Civil-law provisions
60. Any illegal act by civil servants, be it a criminal offence or a tort,
which causes material or moral damage may be the subject of a claim for
compensation before the ordinary civil courts. Pursuant to Article 41 of the
Civil Code, an injured person may file a claim for compensation against an
alleged perpetrator who has caused damage in an unlawful manner whether
wilfully, negligently or imprudently. Pecuniary loss may be compensated by
the civil courts pursuant to Article 46 of the Civil Code and non-pecuniary
or moral damages awarded under Article 47.
61. Proceedings against the administration may be brought before the
administrative courts, whose proceedings are in writing.