X. OPERATIVE PART 140. For these reasons: THE COURT, Unanimously On jurisdiction i. Dismisses the objection to its material jurisdiction; ii. Declares that it has jurisdiction. On admissibility By a majority of Nine Judges (9) for, and One Judge (1) against, iii. Upholds the objection to admissibility on the basis that the Application was not filed within a reasonable time in respect of the First Applicant; iv. Declares that the Application is inadmissible in respect of the First Applicant; Unanimously, v. Dismisses the objection to admissibility on the basis that the Application was not filed within a reasonable time in respect of the Second Applicant; vi. Declares that the Application is admissible in respect of the Second Applicant. On merits vii. Holds that the Respondent State has violated Article 5 of the Charter for introducing corporal punishment, which is inherently 35