ELCI AND OTHERS v. TURKEY JUDGMENT
83
c) Further medical report by Dr Lokman Eğilmez of Hüsniye Ölmez at
her request on 13 December 1993
548. Dr Eğilmez noted two faded, green bruises, 1 cm in diameter on the
left side and lower part of her knee.
d) Medical report of Dr Mahmut Demirel dated 13 December 1993 of
Meral Daniş Beştaş
549. Dr Demirel diagnosed that Mrs Beştaş was suffering from
pneumonia and recommended 15 days' bed rest.
e) The medical opinion of Dr C.M. Milroy, Senior Lecturer in Forensic
Pathology at Sheffield University [GB] (document dated 11 November
1998, submitted by the applicants' representatives)
550. In the context of the cases of Tahir Elçi, Niyazi Çem, Şinasi Tur,
Sabahattin Acar, Selim Kurbanoğlu, Meral Daniş Beştaş, Mesut Beştaş,
Vedat Erten and Hüsniye Ölmez, Dr Milroy commented on the medical
procedures for the examination of detainees.
551. Much of the treatment alleged by the applicants (blindfolding,
being spread-eagled, being subjected to continuous loud music, death
threats, slapping or being stripped naked and doused with cold water) would
not leave any external physical signs. However, the cold water treatment
could result in hypothermia and pneumonia.
552. General beating may lead to bruising and a meagre diet would lead
to weight loss, hence the need to record a prisoner's weight at the start and
at the end of the detention period. A general assessment of the patient's
physical condition would also provide evidence of the prisoner's nutritional
status.
553. As regards Meral Daniş Beştaş, the findings of Dr Mahmut Demirel
(paragraphs 296-298 and 549 above) on 13 December 1993 were consistent
with the allegations of being stripped naked and doused with cold water,
resulting in hypothermia, complicated by pneumonia.
16. Extracts from or summaries of general documentation submitted by
the applicants
a) Diyarbakır Bar Association Report 1997
554. The report denounced the murder of several members of the
Diyarbakır Bar between 1993 and 1995 by unknown perpetrators. Because
of the state of war prevailing in the region at that time, most of the lawyers