SOERING v. THE UNITED KINGDOM JUDGMENT
34
(b) The particular circumstances
105. The applicant submitted that the circumstances to which he would
be exposed as a consequence of the implementation of the Secretary of
State’s decision to return him to the United States, namely the "death row
phenomenon", cumulatively constituted such serious treatment that his
extradition would be contrary to Article 3 (art. 3). He cited in particular the
delays in the appeal and review procedures following a death sentence,
during which time he would be subject to increasing tension and
psychological trauma; the fact, so he said, that the judge or jury in
determining sentence is not obliged to take into account the defendant’s age
and mental state at the time of the offence; the extreme conditions of his
future detention on "death row" in Mecklenburg Correctional Center, where
he expects to be the victim of violence and sexual abuse because of his age,
colour and nationality; and the constant spectre of the execution itself,
including the ritual of execution. He also relied on the possibility of
extradition or deportation, which he would not oppose, to the Federal
Republic of Germany as accentuating the disproportionality of the Secretary
of State’s decision.
The Government of the Federal Republic of Germany took the view that,
taking all the circumstances together, the treatment awaiting the applicant in
Virginia would go so far beyond treatment inevitably connected with the
imposition and execution of a death penalty as to be "inhuman" within the
meaning of Article 3 (art. 3).
On the other hand, the conclusion expressed by the Commission was that
the degree of severity contemplated by Article 3 (art. 3) would not be
attained.
The United Kingdom Government shared this opinion. In particular, they
disputed many of the applicant’s factual allegations as to the conditions on
death row in Mecklenburg and his expected fate there.
i. Length of detention prior to execution
106. The period that a condemned prisoner can expect to spend on death
row in Virginia before being executed is on average six to eight years (see
paragraph 56 above). This length of time awaiting death is, as the
Commission and the United Kingdom Government noted, in a sense largely
of the prisoner’s own making in that he takes advantage of all avenues of
appeal which are offered to him by Virginia law. The automatic appeal to
the Supreme Court of Virginia normally takes no more than six months (see
paragraph 52 above). The remaining time is accounted for by collateral
attacks mounted by the prisoner himself in habeas corpus proceedings
before both the State and Federal courts and in applications to the Supreme
Court of the United States for certiorari review, the prisoner at each stage
being able to seek a stay of execution (see paragraphs 53-54 above). The