occupation by any work or exercise to keep his brain and body active and
healthy; headaches and ulcers as a result of the conditions of detention.
165. In the present Application, the Applicant makes a prima facie allegation of
being subjected to deplorable prison conditions, which he also supported
with a witness statement made under oath. The Respondent State on its
part rejects the claim as unsubstantiated without however adducing any
evidence to the contrary. In the circumstances, burden of proof does not
shift back to the Applicant given that the witness statement carries a
probative value.
166. The Court also takes judicial notice that, as per the 2022 Performance Audit
Report released by the National Audit Office of the Respondent State, the
state of prison conditions reveals issues such as inadequate food,
overcrowding, poor sanitation and insufficient medical care; dilapidated
bedding facilities.76 In its report submitted for the 2016 Universal Periodic
Review of the Respondent State, the Office of the United Nations High
Commissioner for Human Rights highlighted the fact that “conditions in
prisons and detention centres were of serious concern”.77 Similarly, in its
2021 submissions for the country’s third universal periodic review, the
Commission for Human Rights and Good Governance of the Respondent
State, which is the national human rights institution of the Respondent
State, raised concerns about overcrowding and food ratio.78
167. The Court observes that the Respondent State does not rebut the
Applicant’s claim by providing details on its prison conditions or provide
evidence to the effect that the said conditions are in line with international
standards. Given the above described state of detention, the balance of
National Audit Office (United Republic of Tanzania), Performance Audit Report on Administration and
Provision of Remands and Prisons Infrastructure (March 2022).
77 United Nations Human Rights Council, ‘Compilation prepared by the Office of the United Nations
High Commissioner for Human Rights in accordance with paragraph 15 (b) of the annex to Human
Rights Council resolution 5/1 and paragraph 5 of the annex to Council resolution 16/21 United
Republic of Tanzania’ (7 March 2016).
78 Commission for Human Rights and Good Governance, ‘Submission for Tanzania Third Cycle
Universal Periodic Review’ (August 2021) 1-2.
76
47