, - r :~ )
iorro:c
~
6 ~ t t EB
Human and Peoples' Rights
Human Rights ouc
Collective Responsibility
develop, control and use their communal lands, territories and resources and, where
they have been deprived of their lands and territories traditionally owned or inhabited
or used without their consent free and informed, so that they take action to return
these lands and territories. Only when this is not possible for factual reasons, the
Complainants submit, should the right to restitution be replaced by the right to fair,
equitable and prompt compensation. Such compensation should, as far as possible,
take the form of land and territory.
145. They argue that the Kampala Convention for the Protection and Assistance of
Internally Displaced Persons requires States to avoid "as far as possible"
displacement caused by development projects. In sum, these rules prohibit forced
displacement as a fundamental principle, but in circumstances where it may be
permissible, displacement should take place following due process, including the
consent of the victims and after sufficient safeguards have been put in place to
prevent serious rights violations and prevent the most vulnerable among the IDPs,
including children. The Kenyan Government has not taken any steps consistent with
its obligations under international law in the way it is dealing with the Kedong Maasai
issue.
The Commission Analysis
146. The alleged violation of the rights of the Kedong Maasai is based on the status of
the Maasai as an indigenous population, hence the need for them to be classified as
a people first, and an indigenous people second, before proceeding to the analysis
of the allegations of violations of the rights in question.
Allegation that Maasai community of kedong are indigenous people
147. The Commission notes that before pronouncing on the question of whether the
Maasai of Kedong are an indigenous people or community, and for the purposes of
the provisions of the African Charter for groups or collectives, it must rather define
what a people is.
a) Kedong Maasai as a people
148. In Endorois, the Commission acknowledged that there is no consensus on what
a people is for the purposes of the African Charter. It also recognis
nature of the African Charter and its openness to innovative int
concluded that people refer to the collective rights provided fo
~
~
•R t>-''t'
·- =--·
..