children accused of witchcraft accusation in a manner it addresses their
vulnerabilities constitutes violation of Article 5 (2) of the Charter.
Alleged violation of Article 16 on freedom from abuse and torture
72. The Complainants submit that by not exercising due diligence to protect children
from the violence, deprivation of liberty, and suffering resulting from accusation of
witchcraft and by failing to prosecute the perpetrators of these violations, the
Respondent State has violated Article 16 of the Charter. The Respondent State,
however, contends that it has provided appropriate measures, which are adequate
and efficacious enough to cater for the rights of children accused of witchcraft. The
Respondent State provided one pending case on accusation of witchcraft against
a child suggesting it has shown due diligence in investigation and prosecution. The
Respondent State also claiming that there is significant drop of the cases of
witchcraft accusation following the setup of the commission of inquiry in 2010.
73. In assessing the alleged violation of Article 16, the Committee notes the issue for
determination is whether accusation of witchcraft causes abuse and torture against
children and whether or not the measures undertaken by the Respondent State
are in line with its obligation under Article 16.
74. Article 16 of the Charter prohibits ‘all forms of torture, inhuman or degrading
treatment and especially physical or mental injury or abuse, neglect or
maltreatment including sexual abuse, while in the care of a parent, legal guardian
or school authority or any other person who has the care of the child’. From the
submission of the Complainants and its investigation, the Committee notes that
children accused of Witcraft are subject to killings, beating, detention, deprivation
of food, abandonment and neglect by caregivers among others. Moreover, the
Committee notes that in some instances children are subject to beating and
physical abuse in the process of ‘delivery’ from the witchcraft spirit they are
accused of by religious leaders. These incidents cause serious physical injuries
and mental abuse on the children affected. It is, therefore, clear that the violence
occurring against children accused of witchcraft falls under the definition of ‘torture,
inhuman ad degrading treatment’ under Article 16.
75. The question at hand remains whether the Respondent State has undertaken
measures in line with Article 16 of the Charter to protect the children from these
violence and abuse. Article 16(2) provides more clarity on the steps that need to
be undertaken by States to ensure the freedom of children from abuse and torture.
It states that ‘Protective measures under this Article shall include effective
procedures for the establishment of special monitoring units to provide necessary
support for the child and for those who have the care of the child, as well as other
forms of prevention and for identification, reporting, referral, investigation,
treatment, and follow-up of instances of child abuse and neglect.’ State Parties
assume the main responsibility to investigate alleged violations that have come to
their attention in various channels to ensure that children are protected from abuse
and torture.
76. In further elaborating the obligation of States to ensure freedom from torture and
abuse, the Committee underlines that the prohibition of torture and abuse against
22