TABLE OF CONTENTS TABLE OF CONTENTS ............................................................................................... i I. THE PARTIES.................................................................................................... 2 II. SUBJECT MATTER OF THE APPLICATION .................................................... 3 A. Facts of the matter ..................................................................................... 3 B. Alleged violations ....................................................................................... 3 III. SUMMARY OF THE PROCEDURE BEFORE THE COURT ............................. 4 IV. PRAYERS OF THE PARTIES............................................................................ 4 V. JURISDICTION .................................................................................................. 5 VI. A. Objection to material jurisdiction ................................................................ 6 B. Other aspects of jurisdiction ...................................................................... 7 ADMISSIBILITY ................................................................................................. 8 A. Objections to admissibility ......................................................................... 9 i. Objection based on non-exhaustion of domestic remedies ............... 10 ii. Objection based on the failure to file the Application within a reasonable time ................................................................................. 12 B. Other conditions of admissibility .............................................................. 14 VII. MERITS ........................................................................................................... 15 A. Alleged violation of the right to non-discrimination ................................... 16 B. Alleged violation of the right to equality and equal protection of the law .. 17 C. Alleged violation of the right to life ........................................................... 19 D. Alleged violation of the right to dignity ..................................................... 22 E. Alleged violation of the right to a fair trial ................................................. 24 i. Lack of corroboration for the Applicants’ caution statements ............ 26 ii. Allegations relating to admission of illegally obtained caution statements ......................................................................................... 28 F. Alleged violation of the freedom of expression ........................................ 30 G. Alleged violation of Article 1 of the Charter .............................................. 31 VIII. REPARATIONS ............................................................................................... 32 A. B. Pecuniary reparations .............................................................................. 34 i. Material prejudice .............................................................................. 34 ii. Moral prejudice .................................................................................. 34 Non-pecuniary reparations ...................................................................... 35 i