12
GUZZARDI v. ITALY JUDGMENT
36. There is a chapel at Cala Real. According to Mr. Guzzardi, it
remained closed except for religious services at Christmas and Easter. The
Government submitted in reply that the religious authorities - there was a
priest living at Cala d’Oliva – would willingly have opened the chapel for
services at any time had they been asked to do so, but that no one had ever
made such a request.
37. The applicant also claimed that a mass was celebrated every Sunday
by the prison chaplain, but on premises situated outside the area in which
persons in compulsory residence could move freely (see paragraph 26
above).
7. Possibilities of obtaining work
38. For persons in compulsory residence, the prospects of employment
were limited to the openings offered by a firm at Cala Reale, MassiddaCostruzioni edili, which were somewhat modest – four persons in 1975 and
eleven in 1976. The Government submitted that Mr. Guzzardi had shown no
interest at all in this possible source of work. Mr Guzzardi did, however,
produce a certificate from Massidda showing that he had worked for the
company from October 1975 to May 1976 and had subsequently made
repeated and pressing requests for employment, but without success.
8. Possibilities for cultural and recreational activities
39. Persons in compulsory residence could obtain books and newspapers
at Porto Torres, either themselves or through other people who went there.
They had the use of one television set according to the applicant, several
sets according to the Government. The existence of communal canteen and
recreation facilities was also the subject of dispute before the Commission.
9. Communications with the outside
40. Mr. Guzzardi had to give to the authorities prior notice of the name
and number of the person telephoned or telephoning whenever he wished to
make or receive a call (see paragraph 12 above). On the other hand, his
correspondence in the form of letters and telegrams was not monitored.
10. Representations made by the applicant with regard to living
conditions on the island
41. On 11 August 1975, the applicant sent a letter to the Porto Torres
pretore in which he confessed that he had not discharged certain of the
obligations imposed on him by the Milan Regional Court on 30 January (see
paragraph 12 above), namely seeking employment, looking for a fixed
residence and not associating with other "residents" and criminal elements.
He stated that he had tried in vain to comply with these directives and that
the officer in charge of the carabinieri on Asinara had never raised any