Human Rights our
Collective Responsibility
treated persons believed to be members of the Nuba ethnic groups, activists acting
on their behalf, as well as suspected SPLM/ A sympathisers.
As the Commission has held in the Article 19 case,40"where allegations are not
disputed by the state involved, the Commission may take the facts as provided by
the complainant as a given." In the same way, where the Respondent State in this
case does not dispute the factual allegations of the Complainants, the Commission
has the discretion to take the facts as a given.
131.
Therefore, the Commission finds that the deliberate inhuman treatment of
members of South Kordofan and Blue Nile, including the rape and other forms of
sexual violence, violent assaults and enforced disappearances causing serious
physical and psychological suffering that amount to torture and ill-treatment,
violates Article 5 of the African Charter. The Commission also finds that,
regardless of the accusations leveled against those arrested and detained, the illtreatment, brutalisation and torment of those in detention by the security
personnel of the Respondent State with the intention to cause physical and
psychological harm are inhuman and unjustified and amounted to a clear violation
of Article 5 of the African Charter.
132.
Alleged violation of Article 6 of the African Charter
133. The Complainants alleged that the arbitrary arrests of a large number of
civilians, in particular, members of ethnic groups such as Nuba and others
believed to be SPLM/ A-North sympathisers, as well as UN peacekeepers and
journalists as well as the enforced disappearances of identified and unidentified
individuals constitute a violation of the liberty and security of the person under
Article 6 of the African Charter.
134.
Article 6 of the African Charter provides that:
Even) individual shall have the right to liberty and to the security of his person. No one
may be deprived of his freedom except for reasons and conditions previously laid down
by law. In particular, no one may be arbitrarily arrested or detained.
Deprivation of liberty through arbitrary arrests, detention and enforced
disappearances contravenes the very essence of Article 6 of the African Charter.
Where violation of Article 6 is widespread, as is evident in this case, and shown to
have been perpetrated by the Respondent State, the Commission has no option but
to find the Respondent State and its security personnel responsible.
135.
40 Article
19 case (n 32 above) para 102.
27
All Organ of Itla
Africanc ;l
Union \,.,;,'iI